WEBVTT

1
00:00:06.000 --> 00:00:08.000
<v Speaker A>Welcome to the GeoMob podcast, where we

2
00:00:08.000 --> 00:00:16.000
<v Speaker B>discuss geo innovation in any and all forms, whether for fun or profit.

3
00:00:16.000 --> 00:00:52.000
<v Speaker A>Hi everyone, this is Jeremy here. Welcome back to the GeoMob podcast and to the Geospatial Origins strand of the podcast. If you've not heard this strand before, just a reminder that it's about kind of some of the origins of, of geospatial science or engineering and what's led us to the point we're at, particularly through the eyes of various folk who've been involved in that evolution. And today I'm very, very happy to welcome Professor Mike Batty to the podcast. Hello, Mike.

4
00:00:52.000 --> 00:00:54.000
<v Speaker B>Hi, Jeremy.

5
00:00:54.000 --> 00:02:00.000
<v Speaker A>Mike is written down here a much awarded research which I think is true. Fellow of the British Academy, Fellow of the Academy of social science, a CBE in 2004, fellow of the Royal Society, Founders Medal of the Royal geographical society in 2015, and a number of other prizes and awards over the years. I'll save your blushes, Mike, and maybe not read out the full list here, but. And a man I've known since the mid-90s at UCL and the foundation of the center for Advanced Spatial Analysis that I'm sure will will come back to as well, but I think it's fair to say, Mike, a person whose origins and interests have started in the field of planning, I've said before in this podcast, it's interesting to find out people's early phases of their careers and what got them into sectors that are related to this geospatial area. So it was planning for you, was it originally?

6
00:02:00.000 --> 00:02:25.000
<v Speaker B>Yes. I mean, I was trained really as an architect planner basically at Manchester in the early 60s, where we did three years and then made a decision, three years to an undergraduate degree and then made a decision whether to go down the architectural or planning route, basically. So I was very much trained in urban design, really in this particular context.

7
00:02:25.000 --> 00:02:30.000
<v Speaker A>And what was urban design like at the time? What were the kind of thinking?

8
00:02:30.000 --> 00:03:28.000
<v Speaker B>One of my pride and joys, I can't really show you on the screen really, is my conventional architectural models of housing estates, basically. I remember in our third year we did the Lower Deansgate study in Manchester, which was a redevelopment around Central Station and Lower Deansgate, and we built effectively conventional architectural models, basically cork cardboard, a whole variety of things of that sort. No computers. I rack my brains to think whether we ever use computers at all. We use slide rules to actually calculate things quite a lot, but I don't even think we used adding machines or anything like that in those days. So I began from those origins. And obviously to some extent an interest in cities and planning really pervades, you know, my entire sort of career really, in that sense.

9
00:03:28.000 --> 00:03:36.000
<v Speaker A>Did that interest in cities, was that instilled right back at the BA stage, or is that something that you developed

10
00:03:36.000 --> 00:05:43.000
<v Speaker B>into, would you say, I'll tell you this story, I mean, you may want to edit it out, I don't know. But this story about how I got to go to the University of Manchester, that I was a typical product of, you know, the middle classes. I was born and brought up in Liverpool and went to a grammar school, basically. And in the grammar school you either did after the O levels, you did sciences or arts and humanities. And I was quite good at drawing, you see, in some sense. So in some respects the A levels that I did were geography, history, economics and drawing, basically, so geometrical drawing in that sense. And so consequently that sort of pushed me in that direction. And I remember that each of the boys in the sixth form was interviewed by the headmaster and there were only about sort of half a dozen of us, or maybe a dozen who actually went to any kind of university. So we were all interviewed and the, the headmaster said to me, so you want to do town planning? And I said yes. And he said, do you know anything about it? He said, what is town planning? So I said to him, well, it's a subject where you draw plans. And he then said, go away, boy, and go to the central reference library and look up some books on town planning. And then when you've absorbed them, come back and talk to me, you know, about this. Because it was quite clear that I thought of it in a very superficial way. And he in the conversation said, although he was a German sort of teacher. Teacher of German, basically, Although he's the headmaster, he basically said, have you ever heard of Patrick Abercrombie who was a Liverpudlian sort of famous town planner, basically? Of course, I hadn't heard of these people. So that really got me directly into to the kind of planning, architecture planning kind of focus, really, in that sense.

11
00:05:43.000 --> 00:05:51.000
<v Speaker A>I guess it was probably a good thing that when you went and picked up these books that it actually engaged you rather than put you off the subject.

12
00:05:51.000 --> 00:07:08.000
<v Speaker B>Yeah, exactly. And of course there weren't that many books in those days. I mean, in the central reference library in Liverpool, basically there were a couple of shelves of town planning and architecture books, basically in that sense. And that was one of the characteristics of the entire degree course. Very, very few books in that sense, and an awful lot of drawing Basically, Yes. An awful 80% of it was drawing, basically, cartography of various sorts. But it was quite. It was interesting. I mean, the students were, my cohort, were quite sympathetic to it. This is what we thought planning was, basically. Of course, at the same time, planning was undergoing a fair amount of turmoil generally in the 1960s, the sort of. What came onto the agenda was the systems approach. You know, could planning be scientific? And so to some extent, I was exposed to this sort of stuff as well, basically. And that's what led to some extent to, you know, my subsequent work in computer models and GIS and things of that sort, that kind of focus in terms of systems began to change the nature of how we thought we might think about cities and how we might plan, really, in that sense, starting to

13
00:07:08.000 --> 00:07:11.000
<v Speaker A>think of the interconnectedness rather than just buildings in place.

14
00:07:11.000 --> 00:07:13.000
<v Speaker B>Absolutely, yeah, yeah.

15
00:07:13.000 --> 00:07:21.000
<v Speaker A>And so was it straight from a undergrad degree to a lectureship at Manchester, or were there steps in between?

16
00:07:21.000 --> 00:08:06.000
<v Speaker B>Oh, no, there were sorts of steps in between because I was the only person in the department who was. This was after my degree, I was appointed, what was then called in the system an assistant lecturer. And assistant lecturers were essentially, although we never use the word of course, it's an American word, were not tenured, they were fixed term appointments. And in fact, in the architecture planning school at Manchester, we weren't even called assistant lecturers, we were called studio assistants, basically. Oh, yes, it's a terrible sort of term that made you think of, you know, sweeping up the shavings from the 6B pencils in the studio after everybody had.

17
00:08:06.000 --> 00:08:10.000
<v Speaker A>Yes. Making sure there's enough stock and that sort of thing. Yes.

18
00:08:10.000 --> 00:09:45.000
<v Speaker B>So that was. So I did sort of three years as a studio assistant and then I went to Reading and then. Well, I wanted to stay, but of course the planning school and the various professors and so on, lecturers assumed that you would go into practice, basically, that insofar as there was a career path for a town planner, then it was into some local authority or consulting company and so on. And so I decided I didn't want to do this. And by that stage I was immersed in learning about programming and building models and so on. And so I actually then joined Peter hall in the University of Reading. He was the professor of geography there, and he just got this big grant from the center for Environmental studies, this was 1969, to actually build models, basically. And I then went to Reading and stayed there for 10 years that I joined a group, a small group at Reading who were involved in modeling With Peter's Grant. And the other groups involved in modeling around the country were Martial Ashenique in Cambridge, basically, Lionel March, Cambridge Group and then there was a group at the center for Environmental Studies, Alan Wilson, a group at Liverpool, Ian Massa basically, and ourselves at Reading. And that was the basic terrain for, you know, beginning to build these land use transport models. That essentially what I did really for the first five years was at Reading was basically this sort of work, you

19
00:09:45.000 --> 00:09:51.000
<v Speaker A>know, and with those kind of innovative approaches to that.

20
00:09:51.000 --> 00:11:09.000
<v Speaker B>Well, we built on the American experience. The first land use transport models were built in the 60s, in the 50s, in North America, as part of the interstate highway program. The interstates were only just being put in place in the 50s. And also there was massive decentralization of industries from large cities, so suburban sprawl and so on. So the suburban sprawl and the development of accessibility and connectivity were the things that were guiding the development of computer models in the United States from 1955. That was when the Chicago Area Transportation Study Commission was set up. And a lot of those models were then exported, I suppose, in the mid to late 60s to other parts of the world. I say a lot. I mean, one or two were basically. And in Britain, this group really built on the American experience. We were quite close to a whole variety of people. And the development also of urban economics and regional science provided, and some extent quantitative geography, which provided the sort of intellectual rationale to some extent for the development of these models, I guess, at

21
00:11:09.000 --> 00:11:48.000
<v Speaker A>that time as well. So end of the 60s and into the the 70s, maybe it's worth setting up a bit what taking a model might look like from someone else. And also the capacity of the computers at the time. I mean, the computers in that age were not anything like we have now. So it must have been quite a challenge just to run one of these models to do anything useful on equipment of that kind of capacity. And did taking a model from the US involve getting. Sending a stack of punch cards across? Or how did you actually take and reuse models at the time?

22
00:11:48.000 --> 00:11:51.000
<v Speaker B>Oh, no, no, we built them from scratch.

23
00:11:51.000 --> 00:11:52.000
<v Speaker A>Okay, okay.

24
00:11:52.000 --> 00:13:08.000
<v Speaker B>So from the papers, yeah, there was no. People didn't swap their software, as the software was not. And at Manchester, for example, I ran models from about 68, 69 onwards, which were actually implemented on the Atlas 1 machine, which was the main machine in the university. And of course it was all white coats behind closed doors stuff, actually running the programs. I mean, we delivered our input data and our program to the computer center and these guys in White coats basically took away the cards and you came back a day later with things like parity error, you know, so strong. You know, how we ever, ever got stuff to work, I don't know. But basically that's the way we worked. And in fact, I remember that at Manchester, the input, generally speaking, was punched with paper tape and we used these flexowriters to type the program. And then we. If you. If you got a line wrong, you'd have to, you know, splice out the relevant line and stick it with sort of. It wasn't Sellotape. It was a special type of tape, basically.

25
00:13:08.000 --> 00:13:11.000
<v Speaker A>And that's literally cut and pasting, isn't it?

26
00:13:11.000 --> 00:14:29.000
<v Speaker B>Literally cut and pasting. And we did this. And of course you had. You would. You would all your punch tape. Would there be a special spindle wheel type to actually do the tape and so on. I never took any pictures of it, which is a real pity. But, you know, the notion of being in the computer room completely surrounded by literally miles of this punch tape, basically, I could never quite do this. I got near to it, to learning the language of punch tape, but the aficionados basically were able to actually look at a roll of tape and actually just read it directly to read the. Translated into the English, basically. The English, of course, was the programming language. And in Manchester in those days, we used Atlas Autocode and Atlas Autocode was a forerunner, I think, of Pascal or something like that. It was a relatively structured. And of Algo, it was a relatively structured language, basically, in that sense. Then when I moved to Reading, basically we were into punch cards, basically. So if you got one line wrong, you just replace the cards. So it's a lot easier to deal with punch cards and punch tape. Yeah, yeah.

27
00:14:29.000 --> 00:14:38.000
<v Speaker A>So during that time, during that time at Reading, you had a year abroad, is that right? As a visiting professor?

28
00:14:38.000 --> 00:16:43.000
<v Speaker B>That's right. I went there as a research assistant and in 72 became a lecturer, a lecturer in geography. And we had a master's degree in urban and regional planning that Peter was. Well, he was the head of departments anyway, both physical and human geography, but. So I worked with Peter on the master's degree, basically, but also taught undergraduates things like central place theory and stuff like that. And as you said, I got to know quite a lot of people in transportation planning. There was a group at the University of Waterloo in Ontario. It's west of Toronto, about 60 or 70 miles west of Toronto in southern Ontario. And they sort of suggested that I might come as a visitor for a year, basically. So Me and my wife upstairs. Well, we rented our house in Cardiff in Reading and went to Waterloo for a year. And that was really, you know, really. I learned a lot about North America in that sense and a lot about Canada and a lot about modeling too, in that sense. Waterloo was a. Waterloo was again, a very interesting place because they'd got a very strong sort of computer science department there, that there's some very eminent people there at Waterloo in those days. Well, there still are really, in a sense, but they developed a whole variety of different versions of programming languages and so on, in that sense. And of course, the environment of computing was very different. There were visual display units for the first time. Rather than typing in data on cards or tape and so on, you would type directly into the machine itself and save the files that way. So there were a lot of interesting things that went on there, basically, in a sense. And I'd say I learned a lot about transportation modeling at that point.

29
00:16:43.000 --> 00:16:48.000
<v Speaker A>What were they doing differently that you brought back with you, would you say?

30
00:16:48.000 --> 00:18:28.000
<v Speaker B>Well, I think the idea of interactivity in computing was much more advanced when I got back. I remember that whereas at Waterloo, if you had a small job to run, you'd join a queue of people queued up with your cards and there was a limit to the size of the program you could run. You put it into the hopper, these punch cards, and then carry on with the queue of people in front of you, people behind and so on. And the program would run and you'd pull the output off the printer and that sort of interactive computing for small jobs. Right. Of course, clearly the job couldn't run slower than the processing of the queue of people. Basically this was for engineering students at Waterloo, but also for faculty too. Anybody could use the cafeteria system. So that was particularly interesting. And then there was actually for bigger jobs, basically there were visual display units, terminals and so on, which of course were built by people at Waterloo. Basically. There's quite a lot of hard work, development. Of course, out of Waterloo came, of course, ultimately things like. Like things like the BlackBerry basically was a spin off company from the University of Waterloo, Faculty of Engineering, in that sense, I'm trying to remember now, there were one or two other quite innovative computer languages. What for Waterloo, Fortrance. These were all Waterloo products, basically. So that was very interesting.

31
00:18:28.000 --> 00:18:38.000
<v Speaker A>Yeah, and it's interesting to me that it's not a university that's so much in the kind of public perception in this country is some of the US ones. Is it?

32
00:18:38.000 --> 00:19:38.000
<v Speaker B>So, yeah, it was, of course, the University of Waterloo was a new university. It was only established in 1959. And so the demographic of the university in terms of faculty was that the faculty were all quite young. They were all, you know, relatively young. In the early years of Waterloo, I was there 74, 5, because the university had been set up in. And there were a lot of Brits and Australians. I mean, Canada was very colonial in some sense in those days. Certainly a lot of professors were people who had been at the University of Toronto and then, you know, moved to Waterloo and so on. So it was establishing its sort of credentials and computer science was one of the kind of big areas of the university, basically IBM basically sort of endowed quite a bit of stuff in computer science.

33
00:19:38.000 --> 00:19:47.000
<v Speaker A>Let's go to the end of the 70s, shall we then? And the next big move over to the University of Wales.

34
00:19:47.000 --> 00:22:48.000
<v Speaker B>Yes, now that was. I'm just trying. I can't really give you chapter and verse of why I moved to Cardiff. It partly sort of young family and my wife was electorate Oxford, Polly. And it was a hard. We lived in Reading. It was a hard slog for her to do that and look after our kid, you know. And so we moved to Cardiff. I moved to the University of Wales, Institute of Science and Technology, uwist, which was a small college in the university. The University of Wales was a bit like the University of London in the sense that there were colleges throughout Wales all giving the same degree in the University of London. In the old days, if you got a bsc and you wrote it down, bsc brackets London, you didn't know which bit of London you'd got the degree from, basically because the degrees were all given by Senate House and they're the same in the University of Wales. So Uist was a small college of the University of Wales, only had 16 departments and one of which was town planning. It was fairly engineering orientated. And of course, if you go to Cardiff now, the Uist buildings just sit in Cathay's park opposite the old university college buildings. It's all part of the University of Cardiff, of course. So that was a town planning school I went to, but I went from geography to town planning, of course, a lot of planning things had always been in the background in that sense, so it wasn't really sort of that new really in some sense. And so I then went there in 79 and left about 11 years later for the States, basically leaving in the late 70s, sorry, the late 80s for the United States, to Buffalo. I'll come, we'll come back to that in a minute. But Buffalo, New York, which was not very far away from the University of Waterloo. It's about 80 miles north. And you cross. Well, you cross the Canadian border at Niagara. Buffalo is on the border. And so we would fly in Toronto, fly to Toronto and this sort of thing to go to Buffalo. So it was familiar territory in some sense. That was another issue about why we moved from Cardiff. But anyway, as you say, Cardiff was some extent. Cardiff was a baptism of fire because basically the whole Marxist political economy thing had sort of descended on planning, basically. Oh yes, and that was really somewhat counter to the positivism of building models and doing urban analytics and all that sort of stuff. But there was quite a big group of people at Cardiff who were involved in modelling and quite a big group were involved in political economy too. So there was a lot of fiery exchanges really, during those years.

35
00:22:48.000 --> 00:22:55.000
<v Speaker A>And would you say one theory or the other won out from that period?

36
00:22:55.000 --> 00:22:57.000
<v Speaker B>Sorry, say that again, Jeremy.

37
00:22:57.000 --> 00:23:01.000
<v Speaker A>Would you say one theory or the other or one perspective or the other one out in.

38
00:23:01.000 --> 00:23:57.000
<v Speaker B>In town planning some extent. The quantitative stuff did through a variety of appointments. And the one reason why it did was that I went to Australia, I remember, on a lecture tour in 1985, and I also contracted a bad virus in flu basically, while I did that. But when I got back after three weeks in Australia with this raging flu, I was confronted by the head of department telling me that he was moving within the college to become the registrar. This was Mike Bruton, basically, who was a planner, well, geographer, planner I think, but also worked in transport. And Mick said he was moving. And so I sort of said to him, well, who's going to be head of department? Mickey? He said, have you read your contract? Have you read your contract?

39
00:23:57.000 --> 00:23:58.000
<v Speaker A>Oh, no.

40
00:23:58.000 --> 00:25:23.000
<v Speaker B>And one of the things in the contract in those days that. So this was 1985, was that there was no rotation of professorships of head of departments. There were only two professors per department. So in US there were only 32 professors. You couldn't get promoted to a professor, you had to apply from outside. And that was pretty true of the whole system. You know, departments had one and then two chairs. And so I became head of department at that point. And one of the good things about head of department was you had some modest degree over the control of new lecturers and so on. And we were able to develop. There's some good people there already who were quantitative in a way, but we were able to sort of, you know, we were able to consolidate that really during those years. Yeah. And we Got, for example, I became the first professor and so the vacancy for the second professor, Neil Wrigley, who's a geographer from Southampton, a spatial analyst, he got the job as the second professor and he put together the whole of the UK was divided by the ESRC into these regional research labs. Oh yes, the RRls, very important things

41
00:25:23.000 --> 00:25:24.000
<v Speaker A>at the time, weren't they?

42
00:25:24.000 --> 00:26:07.000
<v Speaker B>Absolutely, because they channeled resources and they also gave us a focus towards, you know, emergent GIs in that sense, emergent software and so on. And we were involved in one in South Wales and the west country, basically, which Neil was the sort of director of, basically in Cardiff, in that sense. So the RRLs were an important sort of development in that sense and quite relevant to the development of. Well, quite relevant to the development, of course, of large scale data in GIS and so on. Those are the era of gims and these sorts of software that enabled us to actually draw maps on VDUs and so on. Yeah.

43
00:26:07.000 --> 00:26:18.000
<v Speaker A>So the two things I was going to touch on before maybe moving on to the Buffalo times was in that time period you got your PhD.

44
00:26:18.000 --> 00:27:17.000
<v Speaker B>I mean, when I was at Manchester in the archaic days in the 1960s, the notion of doing a PhD was there. I think there were about 10 lecturers and professors at Manchester in the planning bit, it was architecture and planning or. But there are about 10 and two of them had PhDs, basically. And the PhD degree was not really a training degree. It was sort of more to do with. If you were interested in somewhere and you wanted to work on something in depth then. I know George Chadwick, who was my mentor really there, who wrote A Systems View of Planning. He'd written a book on Joseph Paxton, for example, for his PhD, you know, the engineer, architect Paxman. And basically that was the sort of. That was the notion. So there was no sense of you needed a PhD to actually do anything. Right. To actually become a.

45
00:27:17.000 --> 00:27:18.000
<v Speaker A>To progress.

46
00:27:18.000 --> 00:28:12.000
<v Speaker B>Yeah, yeah. And so I didn't do a PhD then and I didn't do one at reading either, basically. So the one didn't need one in some sense. But when I got to Cardiff, there was, I think there was a sense, I thought to myself, well, maybe I should maybe as a sort of insurance policy. Right, that one should do one. So I did one in the early 80s and of course it's a bit odd if you're a professor and you're also doing a Ph.D. and if there's only two professors, the. The first professor was my supervisor. He knew. Mick knew nothing at all about urban Models. Anyway, there are some very amusing stories, of course, because I got my PhD in 1984 and that was pseudo dynamic urban models.

47
00:28:12.000 --> 00:28:13.000
<v Speaker A>Is that right?

48
00:28:12.000 --> 00:29:57.000
<v Speaker B>That's the one. That's pseudodynamic urban models. Right. Sort of completely unintelligible, of course, if you looked at it now. But anyway, the interesting thing was, was that I also was appointed Dean. Now, although UIST was 16 departments, it had small faculties, and Architecture and Planning at UWIST was part of the faculty of the Built Environment. Basically, there were two departments and I was appointed Dean. And of course, Dean is quite different. Dean then was very different from what it is today. Today it's a sort of resource position. It's a position sort of, you know, running the show, basically, and worrying about money and all this sort of thing. And it wasn't like that at all. All we did was constitutional stuff. And of course, one of the big duties as Dean of Architecture and Planning was to actually announce the. Announce the names of the students who'd got either a BSc in planning or a BSc in architecture. So they. As, you know, I mean, you. Most of us have been to degree ceremonies where the students line up, you know, in blocks of 10 and walk onto the stage and shake the hand of the Vice Chancellor or whoever, and then move off again. And I had to read out the names. This was in the University of Wales, it was in St. David's Hall. And of course, the. It all had to be done in Welsh, basically. In other words, I come from Liverpool and so it's not too difficult to speak with a Welsh accent or a North Walesian accent. And Phil Cooke, who was a Welsh speaker in the department, he taught me. The. Taught me how to say it sort of, you know, literally phonetically.

49
00:29:57.000 --> 00:29:59.000
<v Speaker A>Yeah.

50
00:29:59.000 --> 00:31:35.000
<v Speaker B>And so I was able to do that. And I can tell you now, I start off, but I can't do it on the podcast. I'm going to commit to recording. But the interesting thing was that the year I got my. I did the Deanship for three years, and the year. The first year I got my own degree, so I was also somebody who came up in the same ceremony to be presented with my PhD. And what happened is the undergraduates started for different subject areas, the Deans read their names out and then the Masters and then the PhDs and I. There weren't that many PhDs in the different subjects, so I came up as the last member. But I was sitting on the stage not far from the Principal and the Vice Chancellor and so on, and I came up and it's all been rehearsed beforehand. And I was supposed to then just bow to the Vice Chancellor and then go back to my seat. But the guy who was the sort of the big white chief, Sir Julian Hodge, it was basically who was a. Who was the Chancellor of the University of Wales or something, he decided, he thought that that was a cue to actually move off the stage. Basically I walked up to get my degree. He sort of followed me. He was supposed to sort of shake my hand, but he followed me and he followed me back to my seat. And the then principal Trotman Dickinson basically pulled him back, nearly pulled him over. Basically. There's great rumpus on the stage.

51
00:31:35.000 --> 00:31:37.000
<v Speaker A>There's like a fighter broken out.

52
00:31:37.000 --> 00:31:41.000
<v Speaker B>Ye. Absolutely. Yeah, yeah.

53
00:31:41.000 --> 00:31:50.000
<v Speaker A>So after, after those sort of 10 years in. In Wales, then Buffalo beckoned. How did that come about?

54
00:31:50.000 --> 00:34:39.000
<v Speaker B>Well, I knew a lot of people in. Over the years I'd learned. I mean, I was regarded by many people as a quantitative geographer, basically in some sense. And so I'd learned a lot about spatial analysis over the years. And I'd written some papers in journals like Geographical Analysis and so on. So I'd known professionally, I suppose in this sense, a fairly large number of people in the quantitative revolution in geography. Some of the names like Brian Berry and people like that, I knew these people quite well in that sense. And in the late 1980s, GIS was sort of beginning to get into the ascendancy. Esri was sort of beginning to stabilize and so on and produce software which was fairly portable in some sense. And the National Science foundation put together this proposal for a National center for Geographical Information. NCGIA and various universities bid for this center in the United States. And the consortium has actually won out on this. It was a consortium rather than an individual center. There's a lot of maneuvering position here. And the University of California at Santa Barbara became the lead site. And Buffalo and Main were the sort of the other sites. There were three sites to the bid. Basically this was the one bid for the center. There were other bids from other universities like Minnesota and so on. Anyway, we bid. They bid and were able to. They succeeded in getting this. And it was led by ncgi, was led by Dave Simonette, who was a remote sensing guy, Australian in that sense. And when the center started, he unfortunately passed away fairly early in the days of the center. And Mike Goodchild became the director. And there were directors at Buffalo and at Maine, Andrew Frank at Main and Ross MacKinnon, who was in fact the Dean of Social Sciences as well. He was A quant geographer really, from Canada and. But basically he was dean and he was just an interim position. So I knew Ross and he basically said, why don't you, you know, come here and run this for a bit. And I thought it was a good, good move in the sense that it gave me a new sort of lease of life, really. I was being. I was fairly downtrodden by the system at uist. It was.

55
00:34:39.000 --> 00:34:42.000
<v Speaker A>Sometimes you just have to escape, don't you?

56
00:34:42.000 --> 00:35:35.000
<v Speaker B>There is 16, 16 departments and two professors per department, 32 professors. If you didn't attend Senate, then you got another job, you know, sort of. I remember the printer who was reporting me principal said, where's Professor Batty? And somebody, one of the professors in the Senate said, oh, he's at the Joint University's Southwest Computing thing over at Bath this afternoon representing the, representing the college and he university and so on. And Trotman Dickinson said, well, he should be here, right? No, no, he's. This is a committee. So he said, well, he's going to have to become a member of the Joint Safety Committee or the Car Parking Committee. So Senate was a process of dealing out little jobs and I thought, I really can't stand this on that many committees. It was killing me basically, in that sense. So that was part of the move really, in a sense.

57
00:35:35.000 --> 00:35:40.000
<v Speaker A>And ncgia, I think, was enormously influential in the end, as a center.

58
00:35:40.000 --> 00:37:00.000
<v Speaker B>It was because one of the reasons it was very influential was that the consortium, the three universities involved, decided fairly early on that they would run the center, not by awarding big research projects to themselves, but by setting up meetings, basically, which are called initiatives. And they had a whole series of initiatives which are really different dimensions on geospatial thinking, ranging from cognition and so on. Pretty popular these days, basically the cognition all the way through to different types of statistics, different types of. Different types of graphics and so on, basically. So all of these things represent. Were representing, pulling together different people in the United States and even abroad to actually debate the issues in that sense. So it was very successful and influential in that particular role. The regional research laboratories in Britain were just prior to NCGIA and they were much more like research projects based on the. They too were consortium to some extent, but they were based really on. They were based on proper research projects really related to the research regions and so on.

59
00:37:00.000 --> 00:37:08.000
<v Speaker A>In Britain, it remains a bit of a divide between research projects or research consortia even, even now, doesn't it really, Mike?

60
00:37:08.000 --> 00:37:09.000
<v Speaker B>Those that want to.

61
00:37:09.000 --> 00:37:17.000
<v Speaker A>Want to bring people together in a kind of collaborative Discussion way and the others that have lots of sub projects that they try and tie together.

62
00:37:17.000 --> 00:37:20.000
<v Speaker B>Sure, sure, absolutely, absolutely, yeah.

63
00:37:20.000 --> 00:37:44.000
<v Speaker A>And so in that time I'm interested in how your background as a, as a planner interacted with that kind of rise of kind of geographical information and analysis and so on. But what do you think that planning background brought to you and then as director of that site into the NCGI itself?

64
00:37:44.000 --> 00:40:55.000
<v Speaker B>Well, it was quite interesting because to some extent the United States and to a lesser extent Canada had a very different view, I think, of the use of these geospatial technologies, as we now call them, had a very different view of how they were used and how they might be useful to some extent. One of the things that was different from the UK was that the NCGI covered not only human but also physical geography to some extent. And there's a much stronger emphasis on earth sciences and the physical dimension to some extent in the NCGIA than there ever was in the uk. And that's fairly clear because, you know, you see the same in China to some extent that you've got these enormous continental land masses which, where you have really some very big issues related to how these regions and continents function in that sense. And that really was reflected to some extent within ncgia. It didn't dominate it, but it was there and it wasn't there, particularly in the uk. If you look around the labs in the uk, they're all really human and social related. In fact, the esrc, the old ssrc, the ESRC was the funding vehicle for Howard Newby, I think was the chair of the ESRC who funded it in the late 1980s. Basically funded. And that was very much social science based. So that was one big difference. Of course there was some specialization. NCGIA Santa Barbara was probably more a mixture of physical and human, but there was quite a lot of physical geography there, remote sensing and so on. Buffalo was urban and regional, so the urban and regional fitted me completely in that sense. It was also cartography. Babs Buttonfield and David Mark were cartographers basically. And then University of Maine was really geomatics, basically what we now call geomatics really in that sense. And that was a much smaller sort of college, but it brought a different sense to it. So there was a different profile of the things in the NCGIA from what there was across the board board in Britain, really at that particular point. There were also other initiatives like the Ian Mass and Max Craglier initiative in GIZ Data, I think it was called, was a European initiative which was again different Again, it was again a more a set of conferences, I think, than not unlike the NCGIA to some extent.

65
00:40:55.000 --> 00:41:04.000
<v Speaker A>And the two of their work really led onto many other things as well, didn't it? That kind of European perspective feed through to inspire and all sorts of things, doesn't it?

66
00:41:04.000 --> 00:41:14.000
<v Speaker B>That's right. Agile too. The different organizations that now exist in Europe in a sense really relate back to those things. Yeah, yes.

67
00:41:14.000 --> 00:41:26.000
<v Speaker A>So during that time, what was your. Were you managing to do research as well as to direct, give us a flavor of what

68
00:41:26.000 --> 00:42:33.000
<v Speaker B>we. What we'd done in Cardiff. Right. Not really mention this, but one of the things that dominated my work on thinking about land use transport models in the 1970s when I was at Reading was the fact that most of our computers really didn't really enable us to produce any appropriate graphics. And in planning you needed to communicate this stuff in terms of maps, basically. And in one sense. And computer graphics was, you know, emerging fast with the development of the PC. So at Cardiff I worked a bit between about 1981 and about 1983 or four in retooling myself in computer graphics, basically in that sense, with the idea that we would couple a variety of graphics to the land use transport models, basically in that sense. And on the way in thinking about computer graphics, I came across the idea of fractals, basically.

69
00:42:33.000 --> 00:42:34.000
<v Speaker A>Oh yes, yes.

70
00:42:34.000 --> 00:45:48.000
<v Speaker B>The Mandelbrot's book the Geometry of Nature is a fascinating book. I mean with simulations of whole systems basically in some sense, but using fractal geometry to give realism in that sense. And in the mid-80s I got a grant from. Well, the 80s was dominated by the dismantling of part of the university system in Britain by Mrs. Thatcher. The 1981 cut, so called, where the UGC decided to close Aston and Bradford and all these places which never ultimately got closed, but quite a sort of big issue. And what had happened was that the universities had put a moratorium on lectureships and so in the mid-80s they opened. They decided to set up this thing called the New Blood lecturerships. Oh yes, the New Blood lecturerships were top down funding from the research councils to universities for developing people, for developing young people to become the leaders of the future. It's now called future Leaders and all that sort of thing. But anyway, we bid in Cardiff for one of these. And Paul Longley, who was a PhD student at Bristol in geography, quantitative guy, he basically applied and got the job. And part of his job was to develop some of this computer type stuff that was written into the job specifically and so him and me started to work on ideas about fractals. Originally it was interested because of the computer graphics, but basically ideas about fractals. You could think of the evolution of cities and the development of them as being fractal, like, you know, self similarity, emergence, all these things. So the early days in complexity theory. So I was doing a lot of that in the mid to late 80s and that really transferred directly across into the NCGIA, because at Buffalo, for example, there was in fact, if you looked at the people doing fractals in geography in the late 80s, one of the biggest groups, you know, was in Buffalo basically with Mike Waldenberg and David Mark and even Babs Buttonfield, basically worked on line generalization and that sort of thing. And I'm just trying to think who else. Athol Abrahams, who was a physical geographer on rivers and so on. So there's quite a big group of people in that sense. My Goodchild himself had worked on fractals at one particular point. It was more a cartographic sort of side of things. But nevertheless, Paul Longley and me, while I was at Buffalo, we put together our work in a book called Fractal Cities, which was published in 94, just before I came back to the UK in that sense. And that really was another theme really running through. And it connected up quite well to the whole gis. Large data, Spatial data.

71
00:45:48.000 --> 00:45:50.000
<v Speaker A>Quite an influential book at the time as well.

72
00:45:50.000 --> 00:46:25.000
<v Speaker B>Yeah, I mean, it was again one of these books that as soon as it was published it was far too expensive and then all also academic press, the polishes were acquired by Harcourt or somebody and after a couple of years they said, we'll give you the copyright of this. So we stuck it on the web. Basically this was back in, you know, 1996 or something. And it's been remarkable. I mean, people cite it quite a lot really. Still, in that sense, the power of

73
00:46:25.000 --> 00:46:27.000
<v Speaker A>opening up publication, eh?

74
00:46:27.000 --> 00:46:31.000
<v Speaker B>Indeed, absolutely, absolutely, yeah, yeah.

75
00:46:31.000 --> 00:46:40.000
<v Speaker A>So as you say, then, 94, was it you returned to the UK. Was that just end of contract or was that a deliberate move back here?

76
00:46:40.000 --> 00:48:40.000
<v Speaker B>Partly it was due to the fact that my wife had done a PhD, was doing a PhD in political science at Buffalo. The reason why she was doing a PhD in political science was that the dean, Ross McKinnon of social sciences could only control certain. Could only control the social sciences. So he gave her a sort of a, you know, a sort of a position, a demonstrator position or something to do. To do that. Anyway, she was finishing her PhD off, our son was at boarding school in Britain and about to go to university. And we decided that this would be a good time to. A good time to go back. Basically we came back because of sue, who was finishing her PhD. Daniel was about to go to university here and it seemed like a good move at the time, basically, in that sense. The NCGIA had gone through two or three rounds of funding and in 1995 it was into a third round, I think, and it was beginning to change to some extent the ncgia. The funding was not as generous. I think that didn't make a great deal of difference to us as faculty members. But the funding wasn't quite as generous. There was a focus. There was a focus more on teaching. The UCGIS University Consortium on GIS was adopted by the ncgia and that really sort of pushed the kind of teaching side of GIS and so on. And it was more strongly professional in terms of geography. That was one of the other reasons.

77
00:48:40.000 --> 00:48:48.000
<v Speaker A>But it was. One of the things that came out of NCGIA was that kind of core syllabus

78
00:48:48.000 --> 00:48:51.000
<v Speaker B>that was being written. That was being written, the core curriculum.

79
00:48:51.000 --> 00:48:52.000
<v Speaker A>That's it, yes.

80
00:48:52.000 --> 00:50:15.000
<v Speaker B>Was being written when. Had been refinished, I think when I got there in 1990, 91. That had been more or less put together then by the early members of the ncgi and it was being used, basically we used it at Buffalo to teach one of the. In the Master's course, one of the. One of the GIS modules, basically the core curriculum in that sense. And people like Paul Densherman son Stuart Fotheringham, both at Buffalo had made contributions to that. I didn't make any contributions because it was already mostly done deal. Quite well developed, really, in that sense. Yeah, but that was important. In fact, we've just moved. We've just moved office in central London. We originally were located in Torrington Place, the corner of Tottenham Court Road, Torrington Place. And then we moved to 90 Tottenham Court Road about 15 years ago. We just moved to one 49 Tottenham Court Road, which is up by the hospital opposite Warren Street. And in the process of moving all my books and so on, in a sense there was a copy. There is a copy of still of the core curriculum, basically. And it's three. Three binders. I don't know whether it's the only one in existence.

81
00:50:15.000 --> 00:50:17.000
<v Speaker A>Yes, maybe.

82
00:50:17.000 --> 00:50:21.000
<v Speaker B>I don't think so. I think Mike Goodchild have several copies, dear listeners.

83
00:50:21.000 --> 00:50:22.000
<v Speaker A>Write in if you have a copy.

84
00:50:22.000 --> 00:50:26.000
<v Speaker B>Yes, yeah.

85
00:50:26.000 --> 00:50:36.000
<v Speaker A>So scroll forward then to the uk and how do you end up at UCL and Mike,

86
00:50:36.000 --> 00:52:40.000
<v Speaker B>like all things in UCL and Britain maybe it was very strange in the sense that I was thinking we should move from Buffalo, in the sense that things were changing and so on. And. I got a request to go and think about moving to Berkeley, to the City Planning School and at Berkeley, the university. This was 1994. Five at Berkeley. Well, the west coast universities in the United States were suffering from the sort of the end of the Cold War, you know, the withdrawal of a lot of arms contracts and so on from different industries, et cetera. And in the University of California system they instituted an early retirement plan. And in the early retirement plan a variety of people left. And one of the people who left was Peter Hall. Peter hall had been a professor at Reading and again, some great, great stories about Peter. He was professor at Reading and he took a half time job at Berkeley. This was after I'd left and gone to Cardiff, took a halftime job at Berkeley. And then in 1986 he applied for or he was offered the chairmanship of the esrc, the Economic and Social Research Council. And he decided to, he would take this. And he resigned his position from Berkeley. He also resigned his position from Reading. I took early retirement. I guess he was about 50 then or something. He took early retirement and then what happened was that the government decided that the ESRC was going to move from central London to actually Swindon, basically.

87
00:52:40.000 --> 00:52:43.000
<v Speaker A>Oh yes,

88
00:52:43.000 --> 00:53:05.000
<v Speaker B>in Bedford park in a very fancy house and so on. And he didn't want to move to Swindon basically, in a sense. So he then went back to Reading and said to them, can I have my job back basically? And the Vice Chancellor said no, talking about shooting yourself in the foot. You know, British university, they're very, very good at that sort of thing.

89
00:53:05.000 --> 00:53:06.000
<v Speaker A>Yes.

90
00:53:05.000 --> 00:54:30.000
<v Speaker B>And anyway, so he then decided to go to Berkeley for. Well, of course then the end of the Cold War happened and he'd already retired from Reading in the USS system. And so he took another early retirement under the Californian system and came back to UCL basically. So anyway, his job and one or two other jobs at Berkeley were available and there's a bit of a gap, I think two or three years gap or something like that. And so they said was I interested in this? So I said well, I may be so. But anyway, on the Christmas of 95, I think I came back because we still had our house in Cardiff, basically we couldn't sell it, so to rent it out and so on. I came back and I went to see him in London and he said, oh, he said there's Lots of activity going on here. Lots of universities want to set up centers in gis and stuff like this. Would you be interested? I said, well, you know, I'll look at it, and so on. So we went to see Derek Roberts, the provost. Oh, yes, yes, it was Richard Munton, and I think it was. It might have been Ian Harley. I mean, was it Ian?

91
00:54:30.000 --> 00:54:34.000
<v Speaker A>Yes, I think probably. I think yes, it was Ian and it would have been him at that point.

92
00:54:34.000 --> 00:55:21.000
<v Speaker B>Yeah. So we went to see the provost in early 95, and the provost, in his inimicable way, basically said, what a good idea. Sort of. And he had dispatched Paul Densham, who'd come back to ucl, to actually write a business plan. And I mean, this. I mean, all of this stuff was fictitious, really. I mean, sort of. So he wrote a business plan about, you know, setting up different short courses and so on. Not that I wanted to do anything like that, I mean. But anyway, it was supposed to be this center. And the name of the center, it's still. It's still disputed. You may have a claim to this, Jeremy, but it's still disputed as to who actually defined the name casa.

93
00:55:21.000 --> 00:55:23.000
<v Speaker A>It definitely wasn't me.

94
00:55:23.000 --> 00:58:34.000
<v Speaker B>Yeah. Center for Advanced Space Analysis. Alan Penn maintains that it was. He. He was on the committee. There was a committee of various people like Nick Tyler and Dave Bannister and people like that, Dave Chapman and so on. Anyway, anyway, Casa got. Anyway, at the end of February in 95, Derek Roberts sent me a note saying, you know, we want you to come here and you can set up this center and you can call it whatever you want and, you know, welcome to ucl, so to speak. Okay? And, you know, we'll give you some travel expenses to move your stuff back from the United States and so on. So we went through the motions in doing this. You know, it wasn't too difficult because our son had been in. In the holidays, basically, we'd all come over to the States and so on, and so we still had our house and this sort of thing. So it wasn't too difficult to do all of this. So when I got back in August 1995 to set up something in inverted commas to do with, you know, spatial stuff and so on, I decided I would try and sign on at UCL or Inter. Far as you sign on, basically, in my case, it was to unfreeze my pension scheme. Oh, yes, that was the one thing. So I remember going into Torrington Place and going up to what was called staffing in those days. The department was Staffing. It wasn't HR or staffing and there's a woman sitting there with a computer. And I said well I'm here to sort of sign on and so on. And she said what's your name? So I told her my name. She said there's nobody of that name here. Right under the new stuff list. So I then gave her this letter from Sir Derek Roberts saying, you know, welcome Professor Batty and so on. Anyway, she then took it away and you know there was a large gap basically. And then she returned with this woman who was the, the only person they could find in UCL because it was August so everybody was on holiday. The only person she could find was the senior accountant, Valerie Hobbs. Oh yes, and the registrar of course was not in the same building as staffing. Anyway, they then decided to see what the registrar had on me, see what the registrar had on me. And they found a file on the registrar's desk with my name on basically. So obviously I was okay. And so nobody really knew what to do. First of all there was no space. Richard Monton was summoned and they said well Mike needs a room, right? Well there aren't any rooms. Richard said we haven't had any rooms for years here. And so you know the story Jeremy. It was sort of writ large across the college. You just couldn't, couldn't get any space in those days. Anyway, that was my baptism of fire. And one of the things that was

95
00:58:34.000 --> 00:58:40.000
<v Speaker A>that first appointment just in the Bartlett or was it? Do you have a split appointment?

96
00:58:40.000 --> 01:00:09.000
<v Speaker B>No, it was split. It wasn't even identified as where it was in the sense that I did a bit of teaching in planning to begin with and a bit of teaching in geography but I didn't have a formal contract that said you're half geography or half. I was just called professor of Spatial Analysis and Planning and it was free floating. And that was our great saving grace because we were in the same building where research funding and staffing were. That was in Torrington Place basically. And our administrator got to know all the other administrations. She got to know the system. For example, it was unbelievable that I went to dinner once with Malcolm Grant who was the Provost while we were getting Alan Wilson to come to UCL and I paid for it on the CASA credit card. And the provost and Richard Munson and various people had never heard of the casa. They'd never heard of the fact that heads of de Comm was, could have credit cards. Basically this was the provost, the top man didn't know this. And so UCL is an amazing place at that level. You can do what the hell you like as long as you stay within the guidelines. And the good thing is, if there's goodwill on that sense, you can get things done. So Catha grew quite dramatically and you

97
01:00:09.000 --> 01:00:12.000
<v Speaker A>had quite nice space in that basement as well. Torrington place.

98
01:00:12.000 --> 01:00:21.000
<v Speaker B>Yeah, yeah, not too bad in that basement. Yeah, yeah. So that was the initial intro to ucl.

99
01:00:21.000 --> 01:00:40.000
<v Speaker A>Yes. And so in that period of kind of say, the late 90s, I suppose, there are two intertwining things for you. There was your research interest and then there was the growing kind of research portfolio of casa, which were not the same things, were they?

100
01:00:40.000 --> 01:01:51.000
<v Speaker B>Sure, sure. I mean, in casa, we tried to get as many grants as we could in cognate areas and we were reasonably successful, very successful in the early days. And the reason why we got this space in torrent in place is because we were successful. There's a lot of issues about it, really, in some sense, but nevertheless, it got quite well developed in that sense. And I managed to convince the powers that be that Paul Longley should come, who was a professor at Bristol at that point, and he came and developed the sort of the GIS side because he was working with Mike Goodchild and David Rind and so on. Various people like this, on the big textbook that they produced, basically, and so. And that fitted quite well to casa's profile, basically. What didn't work that well was the idea of a free floating unit that wasn't really in any particular department.

101
01:01:51.000 --> 01:02:00.000
<v Speaker A>And so it always causes accountancy and assignment problems and whose teaching are you contributing to and all that sort of stuff in the university.

102
01:02:00.000 --> 01:03:01.000
<v Speaker B>Yeah. And one of the things was that Malcolm Grant, who was the provost basically after Llewellyn Smith, after Roberts, Llewellyn Smith and then before Michael, I can't remember his name now, but so in the early 2000s, Malcolm Grant was the provost. Now, Malcolm Grant by background was a planning lawyer, basically, and he had a personal interest in the Bartlett and in planning. And he convinced me that we should move CASA into the Bartlett. It should become a unit in the Bartlett. I mean, that's eventually what actually happened, really, by about 2010. And that gave it a slightly better focus to some extent. I'm not sure that made an awful lot, lot of difference, but it legitimized us in some sense.

103
01:03:01.000 --> 01:03:11.000
<v Speaker A>It's made their name more complicated because sometimes it's the Bartlett center for Advanced Spatial Analysis and sometimes not, but that seems to be the main thing.

104
01:03:11.000 --> 01:04:00.000
<v Speaker B>That's right. And of Course the. Yeah, the naming convention is very interesting that somebody told me it was. Well, I think it is a story that came from George Derek Roberts that whenever Derek Roberts would travel around the world, you know, as the President or Provost of ucl, people would say to him, oh, said Eric, we know people in the barlet. Has UCL got anything to do with the barlet? And the issue was that the barlet was a sort of free, freestanding name. Large numbers of people around the world don't know that it's part of ucl. And of course to the provost this was like a red rag to a bull. Rick.

105
01:04:00.000 --> 01:04:01.000
<v Speaker A>Yes, yes.

106
01:04:00.000 --> 01:04:02.000
<v Speaker B>You know. Yeah, bizarre.

107
01:04:02.000 --> 01:04:05.000
<v Speaker A>Mind you, I think the Slade is a bit like that at UCL as

108
01:04:05.000 --> 01:04:09.000
<v Speaker B>well and the Courtauld and a whole variety of outfits. Yeah.

109
01:04:09.000 --> 01:04:19.000
<v Speaker A>So in that time then, where were your interests? Was this the. The period of still fractals but agent based modeling on the rise as well?

110
01:04:19.000 --> 01:07:43.000
<v Speaker B>Yeah, fractals and fractals led to on the one hand cellular automata. Because the sort of basic algorithm to generate a cellular automata generates a fractal, basically self similarity. So fractals continue in cellular automata and then quite quickly into early agent based models particularly because we had quite a lot of interest in and projects in town centres. Basically in Britain we had a Ministry of Housing and Local Government project on town centres, defining town centres and the whole kind of movement patterns in centers were important. So agent based models really came in that particular context. And then. So we had agent based models and complexity and so on and then we began to get back in for a variety of things. We began to get back into land use transportation models that I really finished working on in the 1970s. I didn't really do anything at Cardiff on land use transport models. We were doing stuff on graphics which hooked onto land use transport models. But in the early 2000s we got talking to a group at Newcastle, basically Stuart Barr, Ali Ford and of course Jim Hall. Jim hall ran what was called the Tyndall Cities project, the Tyndall center for Climate Change Consortium of a variety of different outfits and so on. It was quite a big response to climate change and had quite a lot of projects. And Tyndall Cities was the one that Jim led. And the idea was we built a model or various models of the southeast, London and the Southeast, looking at the impact of sea level rise and flooding. Basically that was the prime thing. But using a variety of social and economic models of which we developed the land use transport model. There was a GIS model, UDM Urban development model developed by Ali Ford and Stuart Barr at Newcastle and then the Cambridge Econometrics, a spin off from Land Economy at Cambridge. They developed the input output models and so on. Institute for Transport Studies at Leeds developed the emissions models and so on. So all these models, and then also Mark Birkin developed the, the Genesis model, I think. And these models were all hooked together as an integrated modeling system to look at climate change basically in the southeast. And that's what got us back into land use transport models. That led to Arcadia, which was a broader model, a bigger model. And then in 2016 the future the catapults were set up and the future Cities catapult was focused on trying to. I mean we think that the original mandate for that catapult was to basically develop information technologies for cities and planning

111
01:07:43.000 --> 01:07:46.000
<v Speaker A>kind of on the back of the smart cities thing coming along.

112
01:07:46.000 --> 01:10:07.000
<v Speaker B>Yeah, really, wasn't it Smart cities thing was, was quite relevant to that in many senses. And I remember that what basically happened I think, is that the future cities catapult, the chief executive was Peter Madden who was there for the first three years, I think two or three years. And Peter, I mean there was really no structure to it. It had quite a lot of, of money, but they were having to put it together on the fly. And I think we thought this might be a good place to actually get money to build some of our models and so on. So we dispatched Alan Wilson, the tame knight basically to go and talk to Peter Madden. And Peter Madden said, yeah, yeah, have this money and build these land use transport models. And Andy Hudson Smith was given some money to build some of his 3D virtual London models basically. And so we then began a project building a model that we now call Quant. And Quant is a model not of London or any particular place. It's a model of the whole of Britain, basically England, Scotland and Wales at middle layer super output area. So it's got eight and a half thousand zones. So it's a big model as models go. In terms of the past, we now run it to generate millions of scenarios. We've got it down to about four seconds to run in the fastest versions and so on. So this is a sort of workhorse model that we're continually improving. After the Future Cities catapult funding ended, there was a couple of years gap where we just kept it going in house and then the Turing Instit funded it until last year basically. And we're now in the process of hoping and thinking that we need some more funding for this, basically. But the whole funding thing in Britain, as I'm sure you know, is a real game these days. I mean, whether there is any funding left, God only knows. I mean, in that sense. So it's a bit tricky in this particular way, but the model still runs in that sense.

113
01:10:07.000 --> 01:10:25.000
<v Speaker A>And also this field that you've been in has ended up being kind of very practical in its application to kind of understanding the evolution of our nation and so on, hasn't it? So one might hope that this sort of modeling will persist in being funded.

114
01:10:25.000 --> 01:11:06.000
<v Speaker B>That's right. I mean, I think there's a firm momentum for it that a lot. I think that government is not well geared up to realizing what kind of monies and resources are needed to actually do this sort of stuff. Seriously, they're much better than they were, but they are strapped for cash too, basically, for resources in this sense. So there are problems of that sort which persist, really. But I think it's a much better environment to actually do develop these things than it ever was before, for obvious reasons. I mean, computers are everywhere, you know, and this sort of thing.

115
01:11:06.000 --> 01:11:19.000
<v Speaker A>Yeah, I think we successfully forwarded through a lot of stuff here. There's one particular thing I thought maybe slightly randomly would go back to, and that's the period of lockdown and Covid and.

116
01:11:19.000 --> 01:11:20.000
<v Speaker B>Oh, yeah, and so on.

117
01:11:20.000 --> 01:11:35.000
<v Speaker A>Because that in some ways pushed forward a different appreciation of both the geospatial bit of modelling as well. What were your kind of recollections and involvement in that time?

118
01:11:35.000 --> 01:14:54.000
<v Speaker B>Well, there's a guy over at Cambridge, Mike Cates, who's professor of maths, and he put together a thing called the RAMP Committee, the Toro Society Committee. RAMP meeting means rapid assistance for modeling the pandemic. And this was a Royal Society committee that I sat on and a number of other people who were all Royal Society members basically, to try and mobilize at the beginning of the pandemic, analytical modeling and analytical science, really, for thinking about epidemics, pandemics and so on. And what happened was that the committee elicited something like 1800 responses from different agencies and groups and individuals around the uk, all who might have had something to say on this. And from that we called about 50 different projects dealing with epidemic spread and a whole variety of things also. Things like, you know, things like, you know, the extent to which the disease was disseminated or spread by the disease related to different surfaces, you know, sort of projects on, for example, you know, the extent to which one might contract the disease by going on a bus or Something like that, basically. So lots and lots of different projects in that sense. So that was our contribution to Covid. So that was the more general contribution, the specific contribution we did in casa. We joined up with Mark Birkin in the Turing and one or two other groups, Ying Jin here in Cambridge and a variety of other groups basically. And we developed a model of really of the southwest, but potentially it could have been generalized to the rest of the UK looking at the spread of the epidemic and so on, with a lot of land use, transportation type inputs into it, you know, household structure and so on. And I mean that was a demonstration of how one might build a simulation model of the epidemic. And of course to use the simulation model to look at different control strategies. And so on the paper that many of us were involved in, which is in the journal Social Science and Medicine, basically it sort of, it made use of a lot of micro simulation modeling. And I'm just thinking Nick Mallison at Leeds was responsible for some of this. But I think also the Matzims model, which is the one out of Zurich and Berlin was also used. These are micro simulation models where individuals are being simulated.

119
01:14:54.000 --> 01:14:56.000
<v Speaker A>Right down to the detail, isn't it?

120
01:14:56.000 --> 01:15:51.000
<v Speaker B>Yes, yeah, it's fine scale detail. And so some of the things we talked about during the COVID years were things like working from home, because of course there were certain groups who were, who were mandated to. Well, there were certain groups who were mandated to work, I should say, during COVID And once we put those into, once we put those groups into the model and made a distinction between those who work and those who wouldn't work, basically then it changed travel and land use patterns quite substantially. And so we did some work with these models along those lines, really looking at the extent to which people would. Were working from home due to the mandates and the extent to which this actually changed things, changed the picture.

121
01:15:51.000 --> 01:16:31.000
<v Speaker A>Yes, yes. And that relates to something else I'm a bit aware of time, but last couple of topics here, a lot of the modeling up to a certain point was models, but not necessarily necessarily grounded in observation from the world. And maybe the, the opportunity of what, what's these days called digital twins is that opportunity to link your models to real world observation and have them feed back. Do you think it, do you think that's really going places at the moment and what's your perspective on some of that?

122
01:16:31.000 --> 01:16:57.000
<v Speaker B>I mean, right, right from the beginning, the land use transport models have been validated in quotes against what actually happens. So even back in the 60s, before these things happened, In Britain, when they were being developed in the United States, there was a sense in which one hypothesized the model and then tested it against data and if it was found

123
01:16:57.000 --> 01:17:00.000
<v Speaker A>to be the scientific method, as it were.

124
01:17:00.000 --> 01:18:12.000
<v Speaker B>So to some extent that's always been the case. Case. The big problem now is that most of the validation of models over the years has been fairly low key. The models have been relatively simple and a lot of the detail that we would want in a model is not in some of the operational land use, transport models and so on, not because of any perverse reason, but because it's often the data is very difficult to get and the sort of data that one wants is hard to get. And I think what's happening is that the more and more ideas that are being bandied around related to how we might and what we might model, we're finding that there's a lot of interesting things out there for which we need data, but we don't have data or we don't have data in the most appropriate form. Lots of plausible ideas about who relates to who and how they do it and all of that kind of stuff. It's plausible, but it's not verifiable in that sense.

125
01:18:12.000 --> 01:18:14.000
<v Speaker A>Yes. You can't observe it in any way.

126
01:18:14.000 --> 01:19:09.000
<v Speaker B>You can't observe it. Yeah. It's these unobservables. As we want more and more detailed models, we have more and more unobservable in that sense and that's particularly relevant. I attended yesterday in Cambridge a paper by Tim Hillel, who is a civil engineering professor, actually he's in your old department, Jeremy, at ucl. Tim and Tim talked about one of these sequential math sims type models, you know, sort of with a Travel Pro profile type models that they're building. And he was adding a lot of important detail to it. And the immediate response is, you know, could you validate this detail in any sense? And the problem was the stuff is relevant. You can see that it's relevant. But how do we actually sort of,

127
01:19:09.000 --> 01:19:10.000
<v Speaker A>you know that it's working?

128
01:19:10.000 --> 01:19:15.000
<v Speaker B>Yes, yeah. How do you know it's any good? You know? Yeah, yeah, yeah.

129
01:19:15.000 --> 01:19:22.000
<v Speaker A>Is there any answer to that or do you think that's just going to remain a problem?

130
01:19:22.000 --> 01:21:24.000
<v Speaker B>I think we'll get a clearer view about the complexity of models relative to different situations. In other words, that some models should and can remain simple and need to be simple in certain contexts. Other more complex models, we would treat them somewhat differently. And I think there needs to be a recognition that when you build a model a lot of the time the purposes of the model are. Well, the purposes of the model need to be a lot clearer. So some of the models are quant model, for example. I would never expect anybody to look at the. To take the predictions from the model and actually say that this is what's going to happen. That's not what it's for. I mean, it's for actually figuring out and exploring some of the alternatives in the solution space, basically, in some senses. I mean, this is quite a complex issue in many ways, because when we build a model, we want to use it. We're probably wanting to use it in projection and prediction and so on. You know, why build it in that sense? But of course, increasingly we're learning about the system by building the model in that sense. And the, the idea that every model that we build should be applied pragmatically to real situations is quite problematic, really. I think we need a much clearer discussion of those sorts of issues. And as our models get richer and more detailed and so on, then I think that one will begin to learn appropriate context and appropriate situations for use these things.

131
01:21:24.000 --> 01:21:30.000
<v Speaker A>Yes. Sometimes the interesting thing is when the model doesn't work and learning about the thing you haven't understood, isn't it?

132
01:21:30.000 --> 01:21:32.000
<v Speaker B>Yes, exactly.

133
01:21:32.000 --> 01:21:51.000
<v Speaker A>So I thought maybe we'd end on one last thing and bring it back to planning Mike, and maybe talk about the digital task force for planning work. And what was the. Say a bit about what it is and what the impetus was for that and where you're at with it?

134
01:21:51.000 --> 01:22:52.000
<v Speaker B>Well, it was during the pandemic and I can't remember which stage it was. I think it was after the first year of the pandemic. Wei Yang, who is a consultant planner, that was the year when she was president of the rtpi, the Royal Town Planning Institute. And I didn't. I never met her before. I think I might have known that she was involved in some of the ad hoc Newtown proposals that have been developed over the last 20 years or so. But she came to see me because she wanted to produce something in her presidential year by way of, one might say legacy in that sense. She wanted. She was a strong believer that the president of the RTPI in the year they are president should do something right, which is.

135
01:22:52.000 --> 01:22:54.000
<v Speaker A>Have some impact.

136
01:22:54.000 --> 01:24:40.000
<v Speaker B>Have an impact. Yeah, that's right. And she has a PhD in something like in building science, acoustics or something from Sheffield in the building science area, although she is an RTPI planner and she wanted to do something on the impact of digital transformation on the Planning system. That's a very broad topic, of course. And so we decided to do a survey. We set up what we call the task. We set up a working group to actually basically debate what we needed to survey, what we needed to record with respect to this whole question of the impact of new technologies on planning. Everything from the sort of data that you've been involved in over many years, Jeremy, Ordnance survey, some public data and so on, all the way through to lots of planning applications, data to get a handle on what's going on. Not a project as such, but a report. And so we produced this report in early 2022, I think, which is called Spatial Planning Reimagined or something. It's a report really, of some of the kind of key issues about the planning process and so on, and also a variety of different case studies, short case studies of where new digital technologies are being developed. And so the report was produced back then. And then we decided to set up. We tried to get. We didn't think we would be able to get funding to continue it from the research councils.

137
01:24:40.000 --> 01:24:47.000
<v Speaker A>It wasn't exactly a research initiative, was it, really more of a professional initiative.

138
01:24:47.000 --> 01:26:26.000
<v Speaker B>Exactly, exactly. And so what we decided to do is to set up to continue the Digital Task Force for Planning as a social enterprise. So that's the way it sits. It's a social enterprise. It isn't competing for consulting projects or anything like that. That doesn't mean to say it might not do that in the future, but it wouldn't be in the same manner as the normal consulting type project at the moment. It has some funding. Well, the social enterprise has a committee of four or five people. Myself, Jim hall from Oxford, Chris Rogers from Birmingham, Bernadette, who's a lawyer, who represents the RTPI Flora, I always get her name wrong. She's the professor of Architecture at Cambridge. Anyway, there's about eight people on the board. Basically, Wei Yang is the chief executive and insofar as we're able to get grants and monies, that's what actually pays her to actually continue in that sense. And we have had two or three grants from the Ministry of Housing and Local Government or the Ministry of Communities, Housing and Local Government, whatever it's called, we've had a couple of grants there, which is to actually review, view what's actually going on. Basically, in that sense, it feels like

139
01:26:26.000 --> 01:26:27.000
<v Speaker A>planning has been moving on a bit

140
01:26:27.000 --> 01:27:07.000
<v Speaker B>in the last very much years as well. It's very much at the forefront of what's happening in a practical context, in terms of the different companies and groups who are beginning to develop bits and pieces of software. So in some senses, at that level it's a sort of. It's monitoring what's going on in some sense and providing a forum for making it all more intelligible and a little bit more understandable relative to how technologies are actually changing in planning in that sense.

141
01:27:07.000 --> 01:27:41.000
<v Speaker A>And maybe a final link back, Mike, then to this research career, both in the geospatial, but particularly in the kind of city modeling and regional modeling. A lot of this has been in an academic setting for you, but how do you think that's worked out into the world? What sort of groups or administrations use this sort of modeling and where do you think it's going in that sense of the reach into the world?

142
01:27:41.000 --> 01:29:23.000
<v Speaker B>Well, I think we need much more development in the business of translating these models and tools into practical devices in some sense. In other words, one of the problems with our future Cities catapult project was that we thought that what they would do for us is actually open doors to local authorities. Not all local authorities, but just some to demonstrate these things. And in some sense they were not geared up in terms of their expertise to be able to do that. Basically, in some sense their role was not to do that, although on paper the role was to translate these things into practice, really. And that's been the big stumbling block all along, right from the beginning. In other words, how do you translate this stuff into a form? And my own view is that we need a lot more resources to be able to translate it. We need more resources in this intermediate land of translation. Right. Rather than developing new models, we can do that easily. Individuals can easily do these sorts of things. But it's this whole question of how we make it work in practice and the continuity that's needed to do that. Basically that's another big issue, this question of developing something that has a degree of longevity. Basically.

143
01:29:23.000 --> 01:29:31.000
<v Speaker A>Yes, it's the age old difference between the money to develop the thing and the money to maintain and keep the thing online and available to people, isn't it?

144
01:29:31.000 --> 01:30:37.000
<v Speaker B>Yes, absolutely, absolutely. I mean, we've been quite lucky in our quant model because basically Richard Milton, who's our programmer, is basically paid out of the core monies of casa. Basically we still have to try and get monies that link to his salary in some sense, although he's not on any kind of fixed term thing. There are a number of people in universities who, you know, who are. They're not faculty members as lecturers, but they are paid full time and as I say, in our context, we need to be conscious of providing monies into the system that actually pay for people like Richard and so on. But we are in a good position in the sense that we can keep him. And to some extent the things that he's worked on, he will continue to work on. And that really relates not just to, not just to the software and applications. It relates to even providing the basic infrastructure, the hardware to do all of this, basically, in that sense.

145
01:30:37.000 --> 01:30:47.000
<v Speaker A>Okay, thanks, Mike. I think we should probably wrap it up at this point, but are there any last reflections of things we've not touched on here?

146
01:30:47.000 --> 01:31:08.000
<v Speaker B>Well, no, I don't think so, but I think what I will do is I will. I will look at the previous podcasts right now. So just give me a quick heads up on where one can find the podcasts because there's quite a number of them, I think, aren't there?

147
01:31:08.000 --> 01:31:17.000
<v Speaker A>There is, yes. We're well over 100 now. So, yes, I think if you search for JMob podcast, it'll come up pretty.

148
01:31:17.000 --> 01:31:22.000
<v Speaker B>Gmob is the actual keyword. Yeah, okay. Yeah, yeah, no, I could get that. That's great.

149
01:31:22.000 --> 01:31:30.000
<v Speaker A>And if people want to contact you after the podcast, what's the preferred method, would you say?

150
01:31:30.000 --> 01:31:55.000
<v Speaker B>Well, the preferred method is m.battyclac.uk email is my preferred method and I don't like email coming through LinkedIn because then I have to sort of, you know, pull off the LinkedIn. Well, it's harder to sort of answer it. The UCL email is better.

151
01:31:55.000 --> 01:31:56.000
<v Speaker A>Much simpler. Yes, yes.

152
01:31:56.000 --> 01:31:57.000
<v Speaker B>Yeah.

153
01:31:57.000 --> 01:32:02.000
<v Speaker A>Okay, thanks for your time, Mike. And we'll, we'll close it there, I think. Thanks.

154
01:32:02.000 --> 01:32:19.000
<v Speaker B>Very good. Yeah, okay, thanks very much, Jeremy. Enjoyed it. And I will look with interest at what comes out and I'll try. And I'll look at the Geomobile podcasts and hopefully with any luck, I'll circulate them to our group in casa.

155
01:32:19.000 --> 01:32:21.000
<v Speaker A>Yes, great. Thanks very much.

156
01:32:21.000 --> 01:32:22.000
<v Speaker B>No problem.

157
01:32:22.000 --> 01:32:30.000
<v Speaker A>Thanks then. Thanks for joining us today on the GeoMob podcast. We hope you enjoyed the discussion.

158
01:32:30.000 --> 01:32:43.000
<v Speaker B>You can get the show notes over on the website, which is@thegeomob.com and while you're there, you can sign up for our monthly newsletter and find links to our accounts on Mastodon and LinkedIn so you can stay up to date on

159
01:32:43.000 --> 01:32:59.000
<v Speaker A>all our upcoming events. We hope to see you at an event soon.
